Driving Retention, Reacquisition, and Subscription Levers with Repeat 

Over the past year, retention has become one of the buzziest terms in eCommerce. Repeat, a personalized CPG reordering platform, sits at the cutting edge of the retention landscape. We sat down with Repeat CEO Kim Stiefel and Head of Marketing Alex McEachern to dive into all things retention, spanning subscription journeys, growth drivers, and much more.
October 18, 2022
by
Purple background with the Tydo and Repeat logos with white text that says "The Science of Retention"

Over the past year, retention has become one of the buzziest terms in eCommerce. Repeat, a personalized CPG reordering platform, sits at the cutting edge of the retention landscape and works with category-defining brands like Huron, Osea, Hydrant, Lemon Perfect, and Blume.

We sat down with Repeat CEO Kim Stiefel and Head of Marketing Alex McEachern to dive into all things retention, spanning subscriptions journeys, growth drivers, and much more.

Retention as a DTC Growth Driver

The first version of Repeat’s software was used for Kim’s own DTC brand, UNDR, which launched in 2017. Her team experienced the complexity of getting customers to reorder in a delightful and frictionless way. With these learnings in mind, she wanted to build something better - something with the consumer replenishment experience at the core. What she built worked for her own brand, so she wanted to share it with the world, thus Repeat was born. 

In Kim’s words, “We lived our way to the problem, and we’re now solving it for other brands.”

Retention is a much broader topic than most people think. At Repeat, the team believes brands will stop referring to it as retention. Rather, they prefer to call it first purchase acquisition. 

As it stands, retention is so talked about because it’s the flip side of the acquisition coin, and paid acquisition is more expensive and harder than ever. Critically with the introduction of new iOS updates infusing turbulence into the space, the consumer is getting all the power back. Now that it’s so much harder to get consumers' attention, the real opportunity lies in retention. 

After a consumer’s first purchase, it’s all about convenience. They know what they’re looking to buy, and they’re just looking for someone who can help them reorder on their own terms. 

“Retention drivers span community, SMS, email, sampling, content, product catalogs, checkout flows, and distribution. More importantly, additional drivers are emerging every day as new platforms and channels unfold.”

Core Levers for Ramping Retention

According to Alex, the lever that most operators are sleeping on is the product catalog. 

If a brand only sells one product, that’s not retention, it’s reordering. Put simply, the brand has nothing else to sell. To get people to discover more aspects of a brand, a customer needs options. Over time, customers just won’t buy the same product over and over again.

So, what makes a strong retention marketer? For Alex, it’s about having continual touch points with the customer. As a result, he points out that folks with a background in CX usually make great retention marketers. And if a brand is just starting to dabble in retention, the low-hanging fruit exists in the email world and content world. Hiring email marketers who can focus on the post-purchase experiences along the funnel is one of the fastest ways to see retention uptick.

“At the end of the day, customers just don’t buy from brands anymore. They buy from relationships with real people.” 

Pushing Beyond The Subscription Model 

When brands dive into tactics around increasing retention, their first thought turns to another subscription model, but there are so many other routes that teams need to consider. DTC brands shouldn’t ask themselves, “How can we get as many people into subscription as possible?” 

Instead, they should ask, “How can we reduce one-time purchases?” If a brand is going to pay and do all the work to attract customers for the first time, they need to do everything they can to hit purchase number two, three, and four. 

If a brand wants to consider using a subscription model, Alex suggests creating a matrix by mapping out order value and replenishment rate. At its core, subscription works best for products with low price points and high replenishment rates (less time in between purchases). 

It’s also critical for teams to think about discovering and analyzing predictable consumption patterns across multiple cohorts. For example, people eat cereal every day, and more often than not, multiple people per household consume it. That use case is primed for subscription. 

“The large majority of DTC brands push customers towards a subscription offering. However, subscription isn’t the only retention tool in the toolkit.”

The Repeat Formula to Success 

While brands, especially those with replenishable products, aim to drive customers to subscription, not all customers want—or even need—a subscription. 

Repeat is focused on helping brands serve these customers by building the “Buy Again” button for DTC.

Much like the way Amazon, Target and other major ecommerce retailers have made their account pages shoppable, Repeat gives brands the ability to deliver that experience to their customers, so they can easily reorder items they’ve previously purchased.

This type of experience, it turns out, is exactly what many customers look for: According to a survey done by Coefficient Capital and The New Consumer, 43% of consumers start their online grocery orders with their last order. In other words, the first place they go is to their order history.

With Repeat, brands can lean into this type of consumer behavior and drive incremental revenue via higher conversion rates and increased average order value—with an end result of increasing LTV.

While everyone wants to know their LTV, it’s only one metric and nearly every brand calculates it differently. Alex points out that the key unlocks are dashboarding, creating starting benchmarks, and tracking metrics on a per product level. The hardest part of LTV is the T, or time window. 

When evaluating LTV, brands should ask themselves: 
  1. What’s the customer’s LTV after their purchase in 90 days? 
  2. Of the people who buy this product, what else are they buying? 
  3. How valuable is the customer after they’ve been pushed to our site?

From a product perspective, variety or sample packs are the gateway to customer retention. If a customer doesn’t know what they want and decides to purchase a variety pack, brands can learn a lot from their second purchase. Diving deeper, they can look at which products in the pack have a higher LTV as well as the statistical probability of someone getting hooked.

In addition, if a bundle includes the brand’s hero product and other items that are typically replenished at a higher rate than most, the brand now has a valid reason derived from quantitative data to engage with their customer and remind them to purchase again. 

“Retention is like going to the gym. When you look at yourself day to day, you probably won’t see much of a difference in muscle gain. But over an extended period of time, you’ll see just how much progress you’ve made.”


Report Cards

Free

Report Cards is a customized glimpse into your business, delivered to your inbox for free.

Report Cards consolidates all your key metrics across platforms for an at-a-glance pulse of your business.

Discover metrics for every team member so they can stay updated with the right data on a daily, weekly and monthly basis.

It's free because we believe everyone should have access to the basics.

Learn more
Base for feature illustration

Portfolio

Portfolio is a hub for analytics across multiple Shopify stores. The perfect tool for agencies.

See an aggregate view of all your data for all your stores in one place.

Make real time assessments on marketing initiatives across every storefront you manage.

Analyze the performance of one store versus another in seconds.

Learn more
Screen 1
Base for feature illustration

Noah Wunsch

Founder & CEO,
Ruby
BOOK PICK
Ramping Your Brand
James F. Richardson, PhD
0:00
2:00
Show transcript
Hide transcript

Paul Voge

Founder & CEO,
Aura Bora
BOOK PICK
High-Hanging Fruit: Build Something Great by Going Where No One Else Will
Mark Rampolla
0:00
2:00
Show transcript
Hide transcript

Andrew Benin

CEO & Cofounder,
Graza
BOOK PICK
Salt Sugar Fat
Michael Moss
0:00
2:00
Show transcript
Hide transcript

Becca Millstein

Cofounder & CEO,
Fish Wife
BOOK PICK
The Secret Life of Groceries Benjamin Lorr
0:00
2:00
Show transcript
Hide transcript

Allie Dempster

Cofounder,
Lupii
BOOK PICK
How to Change Your Mind Michael Pollan
0:00
2:00
Show transcript
Hide transcript

Michael Sharon

Cofounder & CEO,
Taika
BOOK PICK
The Beginning of Infinity
David Deutsch
0:00
2:00
Show transcript
Hide transcript

Michael Wieder

Cofounder, President, & CMO,
LALO
BOOK PICK
The Checklist Manifesto
Atul Gawande
0:00
2:00
Show transcript
Hide transcript

Stefany Nieto

Cofounder,
Mojo Microdose
BOOK PICK
The Immortality Key
Brian Muraresku
0:00
2:00
Show transcript
Hide transcript

Cattie Khoury

BOOK PICK
Extreme Ownership
Jocko Willink and Leif Babin
0:00
2:00
Show transcript
Hide transcript

Alex Onsager

Cofounder & CEO,
Character
BOOK PICK
Competing Against Luck Clayton Christensen
0:00
2:00
Show transcript
Hide transcript

Steph Hon

Founder & CEO,
Cadence
BOOK PICK
Open
Andre Agassi
0:00
2:00
Show transcript
Hide transcript

Katina Mountanos

Founder & CEO,
Kosterina
BOOK PICK
Pour Your Heart Into It
Howard Schultz
0:00
2:00
Show transcript
Hide transcript

Dee Charlemagne

Cofounder,
AVEC
BOOK PICK
Shoe Dog
Phil Knight
0:00
2:00
Show transcript
Hide transcript

Cristina Ros Blankfein

Cofounder,
Swoon
BOOK PICK
Shoe Dog
Phil Knight
0:00
2:00
Show transcript
Hide transcript

Peiman Raf

Cofounder & CEO,
Madhappy
BOOK PICK
Shoe Dog
Phil Knight
0:00
2:00
Show transcript
Hide transcript

Libie Motchan

Cofounder,
Fulton
BOOK PICK
Burn Rate
Andy Dunn
0:00
2:00
Show transcript
Hide transcript

Chris Meade

Cofounder,
Crossnet
BOOK PICK
Double Your Profits
Bob Fifer
0:00
2:00
Show transcript
Hide transcript

Maggy Nyamumbo

Founder,
Kahawa 1893
BOOK PICK
The Big Brand Lie
Eddie Yoon, Nicolas Cole, Christopher Lochhead
0:00
2:00
Show transcript
Hide transcript

David Phan

Founder,
Huppy
BOOK PICK
The Slight Edge
Jeff Olson
0:00
2:00
Show transcript
Hide transcript

Cole Pearsall

Cofounder & Chief Sales Officer,
Acid League
BOOK PICK
Business Stripped Bare Richard Branson
0:00
2:00
Show transcript
Hide transcript

David Fudge

Cofounder & CEO,
Aplos
BOOK PICK
The Big Leap
Gay Hendricks
0:00
2:00
Show transcript
Hide transcript

More about the project

Here at Tydo, we try to highlight DTC founders who run their business in various ways. And, that's because there's no "right" way to run a DTC brand.

This project illustrates exactly that. Whether it's how a founder supports their team or how they talk about mental health in the workplace, every founder has a different approach. How do they discover these different approaches? One way: reading. Discover the greatest books that have changed the way 15+ founders think about or operate their business.

You can also listen to these book picks on Spotify or Anchor.fm.

Brandon Amoroso

Founder & President,
Electriq
GIFT PICK
AM to PM Set
by Brooklinen
For the friend who has everything (or when I have no idea what else to get!) this Brooklinen candle set is my go-to gift. It has a classic look, and each scent gives off a homey, exceptionally cozy vibe—perfect for the winter months.

Juliana Casale

Head of Brand and Community,
Wonderment
GIFT PICK
Desert Planter
by Jungalow
A lot of my friends either have a ton of indoor plants, or aspire to be the kind of person who has tons of indoor plants. Jungalow has a nice little selection of live plants in their online store, and they sell super cute planters like this one to house them in. Instantly add ambiance to any party you attend!

Tom Shea

Cofounder,
Adgile
GIFT PICK
Long Jambys
by Jambys
I try not to show up to a dinner party empty-handed. I love bringing “performance inactivewear”—better known as Jambys!  After a night spent entertaining, every host needs time to sit back, relax, and reset. And, what better way to do that than in a pair of super soft, Jamby joggers?!

Rhian Beutler

CEO/Founder,
Govalo
GIFT PICK
The Mini Essentials
by Brightland
Brightland's capsule sets are one of my favorite things to gift a party host. This set does it all—perfect for a charcuterie board or a drizzle on a crusty loaf of bread. It comes in a beautifully designed gift box that makes you feel like you are giving a gift that everyone can enjoy together and use even after the party is over!

Mike De Santis

Direct of Biz Ops,
Doris Dev
GIFT PICK
Humidifier
by Canopy
With winter right around the corner, you have to make sure your loved ones and friends don't dry out! When the heat comes on, the Canopy Humidifier helps to provide humidity in your home! Plus, the built-in aroma diffuser is a great alternative to candles!

Yair Slasky

Business Operations,
Fondue
GIFT PICK
Sampler Pack
by Olipop
You can never go wrong with Olipop—the soda that tastes good and is good for you! Same-day delivery makes for a perfect last-minute gift! I'll be stocking up on a few Sampler Packs this holiday season.

Robi O’Cleirigh

Marketing Manager,
Relo
GIFT PICK
The Classics Box
by Bad Brownie
Whilst I’ve never needed a party as an excuse to chow down on these bad boys, they’re the perfect gift for your host! Easy to share, and a real crowd pleaser, Bad Brownies are a great go-to, holiday sweet treat.

Arjun Jolly

COO/Cofounder,
adQuadrant
GIFT PICK
Sandwich Thins
by Outer Aisle
A healthy and allergy-conscious addition to any dinner, these delicious cauliflower sandwich thins are a top-notch alternative to bread (gluten free and sugar free). They’ll be a fan favorite at the dinner table.

Never miss an update from Tydo

Thank you! Be on the lookout for updates.
Hmm, something when wrong

Zack Elias

Director, Partnerships,
Plobal Apps
GIFT PICK
Open House Bundle
by Life in Lilac
The name says it all—Open House. This is my go-to gift for anyone hosting during the holidays (and a bottle of wine, of course)! Open House is a clean, crisp scent perfect for every day. If fresh laundry isn’t your vibe and you prefer woodsy/smoky notes, Life in Lilac has plenty of A+ scent options.

Nik Sharma

GIFT PICK
Matcha Variety Pack
by Chamberlain Coffee
No one says no to a good cup of caffeine in the morning. In fact, if there was a way to inject caffeine in my veins, I'd be open to testing that. But, the issue with most caffeine is there's always a crash! The crash sucks... you feel tired and unfocused, you just wanna take a break. This is where matcha comes in... but for those who don't want JUST the taste of green soil, Chamberlain Coffee created the perfect flavored matcha. Emma personally worked on these blends, so you know they taste amazing and just as good (if not better) than they look.

Jessica Grossman

Founder/CEO,
In Social
GIFT PICK
Best Seller Bundle
by Three Ships
Who doesn't want the gift of better and brighter skin? Our friends at Three Ships Beauty are the leaders in natural skincare that actually works! Starting with the bestseller bundle helps giftees discover which products (if not all!) work best for their skin.

Kate Cassidy

Partner Marketing Manager,
Tydo
GIFT PICK
Drizzle & Sizzle
by Graza
I love showing up to a party with a practical gift the host can and will actually use. Graza's Sizzle and Drizzle squeezable olive oil set is a welcome addition to any kitchen—plus, they fit perfectly in a wine bottle sized gift bag.

Marcus Ohanesian

Partners Manager,
Trellis
GIFT PICK
Lastra Holiday Mug
by Vietri
This hand-painted Italian stoneware mug is a great gift for any hot cocoa or coffee drinker! If you want to go the extra mile, include a bag of coffee beans or hot chocolate mix.

Phillip Jackson

Cofounder,
Future Commerce
GIFT PICK
Tile Mat
by Letterfolk
I’ve waxed poetic about Pattern Brands over the last few years—and I’ve quickly fallen for one of their newest brand acquisitions. The Letterfolk Tile Mat is a unique gift for any host. It looks on point in any home. Plus, it’s endless fun to customize!

Maier Bianchi

Founder,
Bemeir
GIFT PICK
Haitian Moringa: Hair, Skin, & Nails Vitamins
by Kreyól Essence
Haitian Moringa vitamins are a versatile gift with multiple uses and beneficial health properties. I love giving the Pineapple Rhum Punch flavor! Introducing items from diverse cultures, especially ones from black-owned businesses that deserve recognition, brings me joy.

Never miss an update from Tydo

Thank you! Be on the lookout for updates.
Hmm, something when wrong